Skip to main content

Anglo Indians like J R Barrow couldn't parlay Bengali culture

A sweet, piping voiced colleague reminded me of Bobby from the railway children. In fact she told me a story which shows she actually was Bobby.

She had been travelling from Calcutta to Delhi. He mother sent her when she was 14 with her little 8 year old brother. But with warnings that as they went past one part of the journey, they shouldn't look out of the window, because there were bandits. But "Bobby" did look out and saw the bandits stealing money from people who had got off the train. So, in character, she rolled down the window and shouted at them to stop it immediately. Of course they just laughed.

So she threatened to call a policeman and they laughed again, because the policemen got their cut from the robberies. Of course they boarded the train, probably to assault her, she was firey and beautiful child with long black hair. Quickly she locked the sturdy door of the compartment of her train and they banged and banged at it. The train pulled off, but still they didn't get off and shouted horrible things to her through the door. Her little brother was thinking how was he going to defend his sister but after about four stops they got off and the guard came and knocked at the door to tell the children. When they got to their aunty's in Delhi their aunty phoned her mom. What did you think you were doing sending the children to Delhi on their own.

And I can only echo the sentiments of the aunty.

But this colleague who I only met briefly, told me she was a Northern Indian Christian, there are a lot of them. They are at the Lambeth conference at the moment. And she is doing a very interesting Phd. It's on J.R.Barrow the President of Presidency College during the civil disobediance period, a Briton who had to balance between the nationalists and the colonial authorities, and even so, earned the respect of his Indian academic collegues. This was during the Bengal cultural renaissance with people like Pramatha Chowdhury, Surendranath Dasgupta, Indira Devi Chowdhurani, Santa Sen, Nirmal Kumari Mahalanabish, Prasanta Chandra Mahalanabish, Rani Chanda, Atul Chandra Gupta, Samarendra Nath Tagore, Upendra Nath Gangopadhyay, Rabindranath Tagore, Abanindranath Tagore and Sharat Chandra Chattopadhyay

http://banglapedia.org/HT/P_0263.HTM

The gist of her Phd was that the Anglo Indians were never allowed to assimilate. In order to assimilate they first had to become more soluble to Indian culture. In order to find their home in India they had to revalidate Indian culture and take part in the Bengali rennaisance; so that they could lose themselves in it. This entailed a cultural conflict with the empire, because, of course, Indian culture was devalued by the empire. So these Anglo Indians, born Indian, did their best to translate the Vedas and hob nobbed with Bengali intellectuals and learned Sanskrit - they were concerned with making Britain see the value, the intrinsic value of Indian culture without "nativising it". And of course the colonialists couldn't do this. We read about them in Paul Scott's the Jewel in the Crown, because to value Indian culture meant to lose control.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Aerogramme from Lisa and Richard

To: Mr & Mrs J. Hall, Box 49 Eikenhof (TVL) Johannesburg Afrique du Sud. 28.3.76 Dear John and Nola, Today a week ago we were still in New Delhi with Eve and Tony and the boys and the whole thing looks like a dream. We arrived on the 28.2 in New Delhi and were happy to see the whole family fit and in good health. The boys have grown very much, Phil is just about the size of Tony and the twins are above average. We stayed untill the 22nd March, as our visa ran out and we did not want to go through all the ceremony of asking for an extension. It also got hotter and I don't know how I would have supported the heat. The extra week would also have passed, so we decided not to go to all the trouble with the authorities and leave on the 22nd. I cannot tell you how happy we have been to see such a lovely family, so happy and united. It is rare to experience sucha thing and we have both all the reasons to be proud of them (when I say goth I mean you and us ). There is su

Guardian: Kate Harding's reactionary censorious blog on CiF

It should go without saying... ....that we condemn the scummy prat who called Liskula Cohen : "a psychotic, lying, whoring ... skank" But I disagree with Kate Harding , (in my view a pseudo blogger), posting her blog in the Guardian attacking bloggers. It's a case of set a thief to catch a thief. The mainstream media is irritated by bloggers because they steal its thunder and so they comission people like Kate Harding , people with nothing to say for themselves, apparently, other than that they are feminists, to attack bloggers. I'm black. So I can legitimately attack "angry white old men". I'm a feminist, so I have carte blanche to call all anonymous bloggers "prats." Because yes, that is her erudite response to bloggers. No I don't say that the blogging medium can't be used to attack progressives in whatever context. Of course it can. But to applaud the censorship of a blogger by a billion dollar corporate like Google, and moreov

Guardian books blog fringe: Norman Mailer

FLASHING THE GUARDIAN -- A BOOKS BLOGGERS' REBELLION :  The unheroic censor with a death wish Part 1: In which Norman Mailer stars in an experiment in search engine optimisation By ACCIACCATURE 3 February 2009 When Norman Mailer died in 2007, informed opinion – in the blogosphere, people who had read at least two of his books – was split. The army of readers who saw him as one of the most despicable misogynists writing fiction in the 20th century was perfectly matched by warriors on the other side, who raged that the label wasn’t just unwarranted but tantamount to heinous calumny. Before commenters returned to bitching-as-usual, tempers were lost on literary sites all over the net in debating temperatures high enough to bring to mind tiles burning off space shuttles re-entering Earth’s atmosphere. After I'd agreed to a spontaneous suggestion by our good friend Sean Murray -- a pioneer and stalwart of the comments section of The Guardian’s books blog – that we re-